Nearly three months have passed since our whirlwind
tour of three countries in ten days, my ever growing need to quench my
wanderlust stymied by the cost of flights to Europe. The trip grew from two
countries to three for precisely the same reason – airfare was cheaper through
Turkey. Of course, what we didn’t pay for in money we spent in time – long layovers
that really cut into our vacation time. One layover, however, gave us the
opportunity to walk around Istanbul for an evening, though we never got to
Taksim Square.
Turkey has recently entered the global fray of the
malcontent. Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogen has been the PM for as long as
I have been cognizant of Turkish affairs. The country was a punchline in
childhood jokes, more often than not paired with Hungary. In reality, Erdogen
took office in 2003, but ten years (and counting) is certainly a long time for
a leader to be in power, long enough for his administration to step into the
realm of authoritarianism. Police are attacking Turkish citizens at Taksim
Square as I type this.
I had been to Istanbul a few years ago in a whimsical
trip from Bulgaria, so I knew the general layout of the tourist areas,
which is all we had time for during the layover. Unfortunately, the bulk of our
time would be spent sleeping, as we arrived from Rome in the afternoon and
Europe had yet to switch to daylight savings time. I hadn’t made hotel
reservations, assuming the plethora of budget hotels and hostels would have an
available room. I wanted to stay in the same place as the last time but couldn’t
find it because, well, I don’t know. I’ve always been adept in the biological
art of mapping (indeed, we have special neurons that
help us find our way in the world). And though I could get to the area easily without
a map more than five years later, the exact location of the hotel was elusive.
We stopped in several places with no vacancy and that same feeling about bad
hotel luck that we had experienced under the duress of food poisoning in Rome.
That’s why we followed a shady stranger with a business card that seemed to
indicate he was a proprietor of a budget hotel he said was “just around the
corner.”
Istanbul is an ancient city. I mean ancient, the kind of
it’s-always-been-there city that I like. Born around 660 BC as Byzantium and
known as Constantinople
for a time, Istanbul has survived nearly twenty-seven centuries, though ruins
of a settlement dating back to 6700 BC were discovered during construction of a
subway station. Even the rocks are priceless, because you never know what archaeological
treasure they could have been chipped from. The Greeks founded Byzantium and
settled all over Turkey. The sites of Troy (Trojan horse) and Rhodes (Colossus
of Rhodes) are located in present-day Turkey. Wars, wars, Romans, wars,
Persians, wars… Then came the split of the Roman Empire in the fourth century
under Emperor Constantine (the guy who converted to Christianity from Roman
paganism, moved the imperial city from Rome to Byzantium, and ordered the
creation of the Bible from various sectarian religious texts), creating the
Byzantine Empire. More wars, wars, Crusades, Saladin, wars, more wars…Then the
Ottoman Turks took over the area in the mid-fifteenth century and ruled until
they were defeated in World War I. Brutal at times, tolerant at others, the
Ottoman Empire oversaw extensive development in many parts of the region; some
areas were given autonomy or semi-autonomy, and municipalities were modernized
and expanded. Upon defeat in World War
I, Ottoman lands were divided among the victors. Turkish nationalists fought a
war for independence against Britain, France, Italy, and Greece, eventually
gaining it with the Treaty of Lausanne. It’s been a secular democracy ever
since, aside from a coup here and there.
I’ve spent a lot of my adult life traveling in other
countries, so I know when to be wary of such shady characters as the man who
said he had a hotel room for us. But we were also weary – the time change,
three days in Lebanon, food
poisoning, five days in Italy, five airports, and several trains and buses
will do that to you – so we took a chance and followed him around the corner,
where the hotel was supposedly located. These were busy streets, mind you; we
weren’t going to follow the shady stranger into a dark alley. The hotel wasn’t
around that corner or the next or the next – we winded our way through the
ancient streets of Istanbul, descending a hill into the Zeyrek quarter with its
derelict wooden houses that are barely standing 160-200 years after they were
constructed. I pointed them out to Chris as objects of beauty without wondering
why I thought they were beautiful. They reeked of poverty; many of their
inhabitants are migrants from southeast Turkey who don’t have the money to
maintain them. UNESCO finds them worthy of preserving, as its World Heritage
Committee has undertaken restoration projects in an attempt to save a piece of
history. The dark boards lend a certain harmony to the twisting streets; I
tried to get Chris to notice them but he was too tired or busy worrying about
where the stranger was taking us to listen to my history lesson.
We hadn’t really noticed we were descending a hill. The
winding was intense, and when the liar had taken us around enough corners with
no hotel around any of them, we turned to head back to the area from where we
had started. But we didn’t know how to get back. Too many curves and corners
had been turned. We’d have to get back by sense of direction and periodic
glimpses of the towering minarets of the famed Blue Mosque. Eventually we got
there and found a budget hotel with a vacancy as well, but we were now in the
waning hours of daylight – the shady stranger had robbed us of an hour of
precious sun on our last day of vacation. We’d have to see the sites under the
cover of darkness.
Darkness. These are dark days in Turkey. Erdogen seemed
to be good for the country when he was first elected. Per capita income has
tripled and exports have increased nearly tenfold since he took office.
Economically, people are better off than they were a decade ago. But his conservative
views have increasingly encroached upon the secular state. He and his political
party, AKP, want to force their religious views upon the country, just like
American Republicans want to do to us. Erdogen is of the same mold as them – an
ardent capitalist with little concern for anything but economic development. He’s an
adherent to the international profitmonger ideology that views the world solely
through economics. Indeed, I once saw him speak at the American Enterprise
Institute, that capitalist propaganda organization whose board members include
such luminous assholes as Dick Cheney and Daniel A. D'Aniello, co-founder and
managing director of The Carlyle Group. They’re all part of the cult of economic growth that is responsible for turning so much of the world into stripmall
hell. They care nothing for historic sites, for parks, for libraries, or for
the residencies of human beings if they stand in the way of another shopping
mall. These depositories of drudgery strip the soul from our lives. But it goes
on because people just don’t get that going to these malls and buying their
products allow it to continue.
Then we made our way to the Galata Bridge, with its fish restaurants and fishermen and the harassing merchants so characteristic of Istanbul. “Excuse me, excuse me, what’s your name? Can I ask you a question? Deal for you.” We just wanted to sit down for a beer, not a twenty dollar piece of mackerel.
In my previous trip I had eaten fresh mackerel sandwiches from street vendors for four dollars. Chris seems to have an aversion to street food; we had our first argument on a trip to New York over eating it. (I bought gyros from a truck and he realized I was right!) Instead of four dollar fresh mackerel sandwiches, we chose a restaurant on the bridge and overpaid for beers and appetizers, though the spicy mussels were delicious. We marveled at the giant shrimp and the fresh fish and then continued our wandering.
Tourism is a huge industry in Istanbul, and they milk you
for every last penny. Everything costs ten bucks to enter, even the churches
(though the mosques are free to enter, which makes the church entry fees feel like
a modern-day dhimmi tax.) It
was dark outside and everything was closed for the evening, but the plan was to
get up early enough in the morning to visit the Hagia Sophia, which I had been
unable to visit during my last trip. However, I was with Chris, so that never
happened. Instead, we stopped in a bar where he showed a lack of understanding
about the cultural differences of nations. Though we enjoyed our conversation with
the bartender about various socio-political topics, Chris seemed to think the
bartender would give us free beers because they were fellow "industry guys" and kept ordering them even though I told
him not to. Thus went our Hagia Sophia budget!
As we walked back, we peeked into a hookah café, where
some kids let Chris smoke a hookah for the first time in his life. It was the
last good experience of our vacation. We slept late and hurried to the airport
on Istanbul’s wonderfully efficient public transportation system. They’ve made
great improvements in that regard, largely driven by the city’s desire to host
the 2020 Olympics. I wonder if Taksim events have hurt that cause. (Right now the Olympic Committee says it does not.)
The trip seems like it was so long ago and the city seems
like a bizarro version of itself. The events in Taksim have been characterized
as anti-government protests, but that isn’t accurate. While the protests have
certainly moved on to more general actions of the government itself, it
essentially goes back to the shopping mall. "Economic growth" at any cost. That’s what
makes governments go bad, and that’s how Erdogen and American Republicans can
get away with legislating religion into our lives. (Funny how so many conservative religious types are adherents to the free market ideology, isn't it?) Those who get rich off these
profit-at-all-costs economic policies stop at nothing to keep these types in
power, and the people, who forget their anger and shop in the malls anyway, don’t
do much to try to stop them. Taksim protests and others like them have to happen if we are to save what's left of the soul of us.
Occupy Istanbul. Occupy Wall Street. Occupy Humanity.
No comments:
Post a Comment